Cincinnati Bengals Give Up On Evan McPherson, Replace Him With Another Underperforming Kicker Cade York

The Cincinnati Bengals have made a notable roster change by sidelining Evan McPherson, their previously dependable kicker, and signing Cade York, another kicker with a challenging track record. McPherson, placed on injured reserve due to a groin injury, has struggled this season, achieving only 72.7% accuracy on field goals—well below his earlier career average. His missed kicks in close games contributed to the team’s frustrations. Despite his early reputation as a reliable clutch performer, McPherson’s current physical and mental struggles have cast doubt on his future.

The team signed Cade York to temporarily fill the role. York, who started his career with high expectations as a fourth-round draft pick by the Cleveland Browns in 2022, has had an inconsistent professional journey. After a disappointing rookie season with a 75% field goal success rate, he bounced between practice squads before briefly joining the Washington Commanders. However, York was released after missing both of his attempts in the 2024 season opener. Despite these setbacks, York has reunited with former LSU teammates Joe Burrow and Ja’Marr Chase in Cincinnati, where he hopes to reignite his career.

The Bengals’ decision reflects their urgency in finding stability at a critical position. With playoff hopes still alive, reliable kicking could make or break close games. However, York’s struggles suggest he might not provide the upgrade the team needs. This stopgap solution highlights the challenges NFL teams face when addressing performance declines at such a specialized position.

Let me know if you’d like additional analysis, player statistics, or more historical context!