The Houston Astros should do everything possible to sign Blake Snell.
What might Houston’s pitching staff look like with Blake Snell in the rotation?
The days of only talking about the hot stove are long gone. I know it’s just been three weeks since the Spring Training Games started, but baseball never lasts long enough.
Anyway, with so many false games to watch, the Hot Stove is reduced to a warming dish. Nonetheless, foods can cook quite well on one. This is where Blake Snell and the Houston Astros come in.
Houston’s rotation, as currently constructed (in order, including pitchers who will possibly not (and two who definitely won’t) be ready for opening day).
Justin Verlander
Framber Valdez
Cristian Javier
Lance McCullers Jr.
Hunter Brown
Luis Garcia
Jose Urquidy
JP France
Ronel Blanco
Brandon Bielak
With Verlander, LMJ, Garcia, and now Urquidy on the mend, the rotation is currently constructed thusly:
Framber Valdez
Cristian Javier
Hunter Brown
JP France
Ronel Blanco
After signing Josh Hader, Houston surpassed the first luxury tax threshold. Jim Crane had previously been hesitant to approach the threshold…but it’s possible he hasn’t needed to in over a decade. Look at Houston’s current rotation. Blanco has looked good this spring, and France earned 1.5 wins above replacement as a rookie. Keep in mind that Brown ended just above replacement level, while Houston’s “current” starting staff accumulated only roughly 6 bWAR over the course of the season. If your starting staff accounts for a fifth of your total bWAR, Houston would finish with 78 victories. Not elite.
Sure, use the five “top pitchers” regardless of their present condition, and you’ll have a staff consisting of JV, FV, CJ, LMJ, and HB. That’s more like it, and you can expect a 90-win club instead. The fact is that we have to deal with reality.
The acquisition of Blake Snell will approach and easily exceed the second luxury barrier, resulting in a more severe set of fines. Still, look at the current rotation, which includes Snell—
Blake Snell
Framber Valdez
Cristian Javier
Hunter Brown
JP France
— and hopefully soon into the season —
Justin Verlander
Blake Snell
Framber Valdez
Cristian Javier
France/Brown/Urquidy
That final look is simply an embarrassment of riches, but in the age of extreme pitcher volatility, there is no such thing as “too much” pitching. Last offseason, I trumpeted from the rooftops the advent of the “Four Aces” rotation, and was sadly, very mistaken. If you add Snell to the conversation, and with the return of McCullers, by the end of the season, we could have five.
What would a Snell contract with the Astros be worth? It’s hard to say, seeing as how we haven’t seen Kyle Tucker, Alex Bregman, Framber Valdez, etc sign any sort of extension. What it could take to land him…
If I was Snell, and I need to emphasize that I am not, I would go for a short high AAV contract, somewhere in the neighborhood of two years and $80 million. A longer-term deal with a lower AAV, like a five-year $180 million deal would do it too, but again, I am not Snell.
I’m just spitballing here…building sand castles in the air, as it were. What do you all think it would take, and is it worth it?
Be the first to comment